Asking for Google reviews in 2026: what the FTC and Google allow, with scripts for contractors

Discounts for reviews, happy-customer-only surveys and tech review contests break Google's rules, and some cross the FTC's. Here's where each rulebook draws the line, plus a compliant review process, scripts and a 7-question audit.

By Rivet Editorial Team · · 8 min read

A technician in a navy work uniform carries a toolbox down a leaf-covered front walkway toward a white service van at sunset, with the homeowner's door open behind him.

The short version: ask every customer for a review, the same way, after the tech has left, and give nothing in return. No discount, no gift card drawing, no "text us first if you're unhappy," no contest for the tech whose name shows up most. Those four habits are common in home-services shops, and each one breaks Google's review policy. Some also put you on the wrong side of the Federal Trade Commission.

The stakes went up in the past year. The FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule took effect on October 21, 2024, and in December 2025 the agency sent its first public batch of warning letters under it, to 10 companies, noting that violations can bring civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation. Google, for its part, now restricts whole Business Profiles caught with fake or incentivized reviews, and repeat offenses get longer penalties.

Here is what each set of rules allows, where the two differ, and a review process a 5-truck shop can run without thinking about it.

Why reviews are worth getting right

Homeowners read them, and they read the recent ones. BrightLocal's 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey (1,002 US adults, published February 2026) found:

  • 97% of consumers read reviews for local businesses.
  • 74% look for reviews written in the last three months.
  • 47% won't use a business with fewer than 20 reviews.
  • 89% expect the owner to respond to reviews, and 50% are put off by templated or generic replies.

The takeaway for a contractor: a steady trickle of fresh, real reviews beats a burst of 40 from a promotion two years ago. That steady trickle comes from a boring, consistent ask, which is also exactly what the rules want.

The two rulebooks: Google is stricter than the FTC

Most shops think of "the rules" as one thing. They are two, and they don't match.

What the FTC rule bans

As of November 2026, the FTC's rule and its own Q&A page say you may not:

  • Write, buy or sell fake reviews, or use reviews you know (or should know) misrepresent the reviewer's experience.
  • Tie an incentive to sentiment. Offering anything in exchange for a positive review is banned, and the FTC says a disclosure doesn't fix it.
  • Post insider reviews without disclosure. Reviews by employees, owners or their relatives need a clear disclosure of the relationship.
  • Suppress reviews through intimidation, false accusations or unfounded legal threats.
  • Run a review site you control and present it as independent.
  • Buy fake followers or views (fake social media indicators) knowingly or recklessly.

What the FTC rule does not ban, per the same Q&A: giving incentives for reviews in general, as long as the incentive doesn't depend on what the review says, and asking satisfied customers to update a review. Contacting an unhappy reviewer to fix their problem is also fine.

On "review gating" (asking only the customers you think are happy), the FTC says the rule has no specific prohibition, but warns the practice could still violate the FTC Act.

What Google's policy bans

Google's Maps contribution policy goes further. It says merchants may not:

  • Offer incentives "in exchange for posting any review", including payment, discounts, free goods or services. That word "any" matters: on Google, even an incentive for an honest review is out.
  • Discourage negative reviews or "selectively solicit positive reviews." Review gating is flatly prohibited on Google.
  • Pressure customers to leave reviews "while on the premises" or ask for specific content.
  • Ask staff to collect a certain number of reviews, or ask staff to get reviews with specific content, "including content that identifies a staff member."
  • Post reviews with a conflict of interest, which Google says can include current or former employment, contractual relationships, family ties and competitors.

What Google explicitly allows: asking customers to post reviews of genuine experiences, "without offering incentives to do so or attempting to influence the rating or the contents of the review."

The practical rule

If a practice is legal under the FTC rule but banned by Google, it's still banned for your Google profile, and that's where most of your reviews live. Build your process to Google's standard and you'll clear the FTC's too.

Four common contractor habits that break the rules

1. "$25 off your next tune-up for a review"

Fine under the FTC rule if it truly doesn't depend on the star rating. Not fine on Google, which bans incentives for any review. Same for raffles, gift card drawings and "free filter with your review."

Fix: Drop the incentive. If you want to reward customers, run the discount for everyone, with no connection to reviewing.

2. "How did we do? Tap 5 stars to review us on Google, or tell us what went wrong."

This is review gating: happy customers get routed to Google, unhappy ones to a private form. Google bans selective solicitation outright, and the FTC warns it may violate the FTC Act.

Fix: Send every customer the same link to the same public review page. You can still offer a way to reach the office, but it can't be a filter in front of the review link.

3. The tech review leaderboard

"Most reviews that mention you by name this month wins $100." Google's policy names this almost exactly: asking staff to solicit a certain number of reviews, or reviews that include content identifying a staff member.

Fix: Reward techs on things they control and you can measure without touching review content: callbacks, first-time fix rate, membership sign-ups, on-time arrivals. If you want to share kind reviews that mention a tech, do it as recognition, not as a scored target.

4. Handing the customer a tablet at the kitchen table

Google says merchants shouldn't "require or pressure" customers to review while on the premises. For a service business, the customer's home is where the tech is standing, and a tech holding out a tablet is pressure.

Fix: The tech mentions that a text is coming, then the office or your software sends the link after the truck has left.

Two smaller ones while you're auditing: don't let employees, family or your marketing agency review the business, and never threaten a customer over a bad review. The first is a conflict of interest on Google and needs disclosure under the FTC rule; the second is review suppression.

A review process that follows both rulebooks

Here's a process that fits a 1-to-30-tech shop and needs no judgment calls in the field.

Step 1: Ask everyone, automatically

Trigger the review request from the job status, not from the tech's read of the customer. When a job is marked complete and paid, the customer gets the request. Every job, every customer, same timing. That consistency is your best evidence that you're not gating.

Step 2: Send it a couple of hours after the job

Long enough that the tech is gone, soon enough that the visit is fresh. If you text customers, keep the request inside the messaging consent you already have and honor opt-outs.

Step 3: Use a neutral script

Text version:

Hi Dana, thanks for having us out today for your water heater. If you have a minute, we'd appreciate an honest review on Google: [link]. Questions about the work? Reply here or call the office.

What makes it compliant: it goes to everyone, it asks for an honest review rather than a 5-star one, there's no reward, and the "call the office" line sits after the review link instead of in front of it.

What the tech says at the door:

You'll get a text from the office later today with a link to review us on Google. Honest feedback helps us a lot.

Step 4: Give the tech a script for unhappy customers

If the customer is upset, the tech's job is to fix the problem or get the office involved, not to steer the review. "Let me get the office on this today" is the right move. "Please don't leave a review until we sort this out" is discouraging negative reviews.

Step 5: Reply to every review within a week

BrightLocal's 2026 survey found 81% of consumers expect a response within a week and half dislike templated replies. Three lines is enough:

  • Positive: Thank them, name the job ("glad the new panel is working"), and invite them back.
  • Negative: Acknowledge it, don't argue in public, give a name and number, and take it offline.
  • Possibly fake (no record of the customer): Reply calmly that you can't find the job and invite them to call, then flag it through your Business Profile.

Step 6: Clean up old habits

If you ran incentives or a gated survey in the past, stop now and change the templates in your field software. Google can remove reviews it believes were incentivized. Under its "Business Profile restrictions" policy, Google says a profile caught with fake engagement can:

  • be blocked from getting new reviews or ratings for a set period,
  • have its existing reviews unpublished for a set period, or
  • display a public warning that fake reviews were removed.

Google says it emails the owner before applying a restriction and that businesses can appeal. Search Engine Roundtable reported in July 2026 that repeat violations can draw longer restrictions, citing a notice that blocked new and past reviews for two months after additional incentivized reviews were found.

For a contractor, losing visible reviews for a month in peak season is a real hit to calls.

A five-minute audit you can run today

Answer yes or no:

  1. Does every completed job trigger the same review request? (You want yes.)
  2. Is there any discount, drawing or gift tied to leaving a review? (You want no.)
  3. Does your survey or text route only happy customers to Google? (No.)
  4. Do techs have review quotas, or get paid per review or per name mention? (No.)
  5. Do techs ask for reviews on a device in the customer's home? (No.)
  6. Have employees, relatives or your agency reviewed the business? (No, or disclosed.)
  7. Have you replied to every review from the last 90 days? (Yes.)

Any wrong answer is a template, a pay plan or a habit you can change this week.

The good news is that the compliant process is also the one that works best: asking everyone produces a steady stream of fresh reviews, and fresh reviews are what homeowners look at. And none of it works if the customer never got through to book the job in the first place, so make sure your phones are covered too. If after-hours calls are a gap, an AI receptionist like Rivet can answer 24/7, tell callers it's an AI, book the job onto your calendar and send you the summary, so the customer you'd later ask for a review actually became a customer.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For questions about your specific situation, talk to an attorney.

Sources

  1. FTC: Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule questions and answers
  2. FTC: warning letters to 10 companies about possible Consumer Review Rule violations (Dec. 22, 2025)
  3. Google Maps user contributed content policy: prohibited and restricted content
  4. Google Business Profile: restrictions for policy violations
  5. BrightLocal: Local Consumer Review Survey 2026
  6. Search Engine Roundtable: Google Business Profile restrictions can double for repeat violations (July 2026)

Keep reading